Criticism - Copping It Sweet!Not everyone is going to like what you write

The one undeniable fact about writing and publishing books and expressing your opinion via a blog is that you are not going to be liked, appreciated, loved or in some cases, even tolerated by some readers.

While some disagree politely, others can be downright rude, and then there are even a few who think that throwing a few choice insults is fair enough.

Whether it be by way of a blog comment, a blog post, a social media post or a book review, when you express an opinion, you just have to accept that you are not going to be liked by all and that in some cases, you can even offend a few people without intending to do so.

I only mention this because I stumbled across a post on another blog today by sheer accident, which linked back to one of my earlier blog posts. The blog post was well written, and while agreeing with some of my points, it disagreed with others. In all, an honest opinion and I appreciated the link and quotes.

What I didn’t really appreciate was a lengthy anonymous comment on this post that was particularly nasty. It didn’t comment on the actual post but launched into a personal attack on me.  While I just ‘copped it sweet’, I did find it a little distasteful that this commenter had obviously read my original post, but was a little shy in posting the attack on my own blog.

So what do you do when the brickbats start arriving?

The simple answer is nothing.

Just as I have the right to express my opinion in whatever forum I feel inclined, so does everyone else. Including the not so nice commenter I mentioned. As I have said before in some of my posts about communication on the Internet, never ‘flare‘. By that I mean, never enter into an argument, of try to justify yourself with emotive reactions. Just accept that it will and does happen and ‘cop it sweet’ in silence.

EXCEPT, when I did a little research into this particular commenter, who hid behind a screen name, I discovered something. This person is an Amazon reviewer, who reviews a number of things including books, solar LED lanterns, head massagers, lemon press sets, IQ treat balls and even VCT – 220V/240V AC 16A Universal Surge Protector / Power Strip with 6 Universal Outlets. 50Hz/60Hz – 450 Joules. Max. 4000 Watt Capacity – Heavy Duty European Cords!

Now I will let you be the judge as to whether this Amazon reviewer is paid for reviewing power cords or not, but enough to say that well, if you may excuse me, for smelling a rat.

I’m sorry, but this little episode has not only increased my belief that Amazon reviews are now so tainted that it’s hardly worth reading them, but worse, that these Amazon reviewers are now being used to conduct personal attacks outside of the Amazon arena. I’ll let you draw your own conclusion as to whether they are paid to peddle their malicious wares.

As usual, I will cop this in silence, but be aware, there are those who seem to want to play very unfairly.

Criticism – Copping It Sweet!
Tagged on:                             

11 thoughts on “Criticism – Copping It Sweet!

  • 09/10/2012 at 11:06 pm
    Permalink

    One of my writer friends got a review that was so awful that she nearly stopped writing.

    Maybe you shouldn’t read your reviews anymore. A lot of writers don’t because of nasty reviews.

    Janice~

  • 09/10/2012 at 11:14 pm
    Permalink

    I have come across some VERY nasty reviews on Amazon and I always think it’s such a shame. I understand that people have a right to their own opinion but what every happened to being polite? Can’t we not like something but at the same time still be nice about it?

    • 10/10/2012 at 9:03 am
      Permalink

      Oh Shannon if only that were the case. Sadly these days it appears there is no room for ‘polite’ anymore…

  • 10/10/2012 at 12:51 pm
    Permalink

    Hi Derek, would you consider posting the link to this other blog post? Would love to read it for myself. but I admire you for keeping your cool. You are a great example for all of us.
    I’ve also had a few reviews which have raised my hackles, where I felt an immediate need to justify myself. But once I stewed about it for a few days, I decided, as you did, that everyone is entitled to their opinion, so there’s no point in entering into a heated debate.
    But there is one review on Apple in the UK, where the reviewer actually put a spoiler in the review, and I have noticed that it has had a negative impact on sales. And it isn’t a British thing, because on Amazon UK sales are fine. But as the penguins in the Madagascar movie always say: “Smile and wave, boys, smile and wave.” Always make me laugh.

    • 10/10/2012 at 1:26 pm
      Permalink

      While it’s very tempting to publish a link to this comment Niki, I have to stand by my decision not to. The offending comment stands out in a long list of comments as being a ‘troll’, as it is so clearly off topic and offensive, that I think most people are smart enough to work it out if they read the post.

      The other reason is that by giving any exposure to ‘trolls’, it is doing exactly what they want.

  • 10/10/2012 at 2:20 pm
    Permalink

    I’m still enjoying reviewing and posting in many places for all the authors who are nice enough to ask me and send me their books.

    I’m neither tainted or nasty. I also do not receive money for reviewing.

    Mary

    • 10/10/2012 at 3:15 pm
      Permalink

      You missed one very important quality about yourself Mary. You are THE MOST HONEST reviewer I know!!

  • 11/10/2012 at 9:57 am
    Permalink

    Thank you Derek and Jack! :)))

Comments are closed.